Part 2: Origins and History

Naturopathy · Part 2 of 6

Naturopathy’s history runs in three acts. It began as nature cure – a European movement of water, air, diet and rest built on a single, sweeping theory of illness. It was named and exported to America by one determined immigrant, flourished, and then nearly vanished. And it was rebuilt from the 1950s onward as a licensed, science-oriented profession. That rebuilding saved naturopathy – and it is also where the field traded its own model of the body for biomedicine’s.

Part 1 argued that modern naturopathy holds holistic values but mostly reasons with a borrowed, diagnosis-by-diagnosis model. History explains how that happened. The surprise is that early naturopathy was more systemic than today’s, not less. It had a unified theory of disease – one that was wrong in important ways, but unified all the same. What the profession later discarded, and what it failed to replace, is the thread worth following through this part.

Before the name: European nature cure

The idea at naturopathy’s root is ancient. Vis medicatrix naturae – the healing power of nature – goes back to the Hippocratic writings, which held that the physician’s job was largely to support a body already trying to heal itself. But naturopathy’s direct ancestor is a 19th-century movement in the German-speaking world, born partly in reaction to the same harsh medicine – bloodletting, mercury, purging – that drove Hahnemann toward homeopathy.

FigureEraContribution
Vincent Priessnitz1820s–1850sA Silesian farmer who built a famous water-cure establishment at Gräfenberg, drawing patients from across Europe
Sebastian Kneipp1850s–1897A Bavarian priest whose system of cold-water applications, herbs, exercise, diet and spiritual balance became enormously popular; his My Water Cure (1886) was a bestseller
Arnold Rikli1850s–1900sSwiss practitioner of “atmospheric cure” – sun, light and air baths
Louis Kuhne1880s–1900sProposed in The New Science of Healing (1891) that all disease arises from one cause: accumulated “foreign matter” in the body

What unites these figures is a regimen, not a pharmacy. Nature cure treated illness mainly by changing how a person lived – water, air, light, food, movement and rest – and only secondarily with herbs. Kuhne’s “unity of disease” is the clearest statement of its underlying logic: many symptoms, one disturbed terrain, one direction of treatment. That idea would not survive modern physiology. But it was a genuinely systemic model, and it is the opposite of matching a substance to a symptom.

Benedict Lust and the American founding

Naturopathy as a named profession is largely the work of one man. Benedict Lust (1872–1945) emigrated from Germany to New York as a young man, fell seriously ill with tuberculosis, and returned home to be treated by Kneipp himself. He recovered, and came back to America as Kneipp’s representative, determined to spread the water cure.

Lust soon outgrew a single method. In 1902 he adopted the term naturopathy – coined a few years earlier by a New York physician, John Scheel – to describe something broader: an umbrella for every drug-free, “natural” approach he could gather. He founded the American School of Naturopathy in New York, opened health resorts, published magazines, and organized the profession that became the American Naturopathic Association.

That breadth was Lust’s gift and the profession’s lasting signature. Under one roof he placed hydrotherapy, diet reform, herbalism, fasting, homeopathy, spinal manipulation, exercise and more. Naturopathy was, from the beginning, defined by what it excluded – surgery and synthetic drugs – rather than by a single positive method. That made it welcoming and flexible. It also planted the seed of the problem Part 1 described: a profession held together by a philosophy and a list of permitted tools, rather than one way of reading a patient.

The model naturopathy once had

If Lust gave naturopathy its name and breadth, Henry Lindlahr (1862–1924) gave it a theory. A Chicago physician who had himself turned to nature cure after illness, Lindlahr ran a sanitarium and college and wrote Nature Cure (1913) and the multi-volume Philosophy of Natural Therapeutics. His framework was the closest early naturopathy came to a unified clinical model.

ConceptLindlahr’s claim
Unity of diseaseMost illness springs from a small set of root causes: lowered vitality, abnormal blood composition, and the accumulation of waste and toxins
Acute illness as healingFevers, inflammation and discharges are the body’s attempt to cleanse itself – a healing crisis to be supported, not stopped
SuppressionDrugs that shut down acute symptoms drive the disturbance deeper, turning acute illness into chronic disease
Law of cureTrue healing moves from within outward and in reverse order of the symptoms’ appearance – an idea shared with homeopathy

Read fairly, this model has two faces. On one side it was genuinely systemic: it read every symptom as part of one process in one person, and it gave practitioners a reason to work on the whole terrain first. On the other side, much of it was simply wrong. The theory of “autointoxication” – that waste absorbed from the bowel poisons the body – was abandoned by physiology, and the general hostility to suppressing symptoms sat badly with the arrival of vaccines and antibiotics that suppressed infections and saved lives.

This is the important historical point for the whole series. Early naturopathy did have its own model of the body. It was unified and holistic, and in key respects mistaken. The question the profession later faced was not whether to keep it unchanged, but what, if anything, would replace it.

Decline: Flexner, the AMA, and antibiotics

Naturopathy flourished in the 1920s and 1930s, with schools across the country, licensing laws in a number of states, and a wide popular following. Within a generation it had nearly disappeared. Three forces did it, and they deserve to be named separately rather than blurred into one story.

Educational reform. The 1910 Flexner Report, discussed in the homeopathy series, held every medical school to the standard of laboratory science. Naturopathic schools – small, often proprietary, with uneven training – could not meet it, and the reform’s long tail closed or isolated them.

Organized opposition. The American Medical Association campaigned hard against naturopathy, as it had against homeopathy. Morris Fishbein, editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association from 1924 to 1949, attacked Lust and his colleagues as quacks in print. Lust himself was arrested many times for practicing without a medical license. Some of that opposition was professional and economic boundary-drawing; some of it was aimed at genuinely dangerous claims. Both were present.

Medicine got much better. This is the force most often left out of sympathetic histories, and it may have mattered most. Sulfa drugs in the 1930s and penicillin in the 1940s transformed the treatment of infection – the very territory where nature cure’s “support the healing crisis” approach had been weakest. Patients voted with their feet. After Lust’s death in 1945, many states repealed naturopathic licensing, and by the 1960s only a handful of practitioners and one or two schools remained.

As with homeopathy, a fair history holds both halves. Naturopathy was partly out-organized by a rising profession, and partly out-performed by a medicine that had finally become effective. Either story alone is too tidy.

The rebuilding – and where the borrowed model came in

The revival began small. In 1956 a group of naturopaths founded the National College of Naturopathic Medicine in Portland, Oregon (now the National University of Natural Medicine), keeping a training pipeline alive through the lean decades. In Seattle, the physician John Bastyr (1912–1995) became the quiet mentor of a younger generation, known for insisting that natural medicine engage seriously with the scientific literature.

That generation rebuilt the profession on a deliberate bargain. In 1978 Joseph Pizzorno and colleagues founded what became Bastyr University, under the banner of science-based natural medicine. The same year saw the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education formed to accredit schools, and the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine founded in Toronto. A standardized licensing exam followed in 1986, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians in 1985, and in 1989 the six principles described in Part 1.

The new curriculum looked, in its first two years, much like a medical school’s: anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, pathology, physical and laboratory diagnosis. This is the hinge of the series’ argument. The old Lindlahr model was dropped – rightly, in many respects – but it was not replaced with a new naturopathic model of the body. Instead, the profession adopted biomedicine’s diagnostic map whole and kept its own identity in two places: the philosophy (the six principles, later the therapeutic order) and the toolkit (botanicals, nutrients, hydrotherapy, homeopathy).

From the 1990s, the rise of functional medicine reinforced the pattern. Its emphasis on extended laboratory panels – hormones, micronutrients, gut markers – gave naturopaths a new, more detailed list of abnormalities to correct, each with its natural agent. That made practice more precise and more marketable. It also made the logic of find the abnormality, supply the corrective more central, not less.

What the rebuilding achieved, and what it cost. It made naturopathy safer, more credible, better trained in red flags, and licensable – real gains for patients. And it left the profession with holistic values sitting on top of a reductionist diagnostic engine. That is the gap Part 1 called green allopathy, and it was built in during these decades.

Milestones at a glance

YearMilestone
1820sPriessnitz’s water cure at Gräfenberg draws patients from across Europe
1886Kneipp publishes My Water Cure
1891Kuhne’s The New Science of Healing sets out the “unity of disease”
1902Benedict Lust adopts the name naturopathy; the American School of Naturopathy follows in New York
1910The Flexner Report begins reshaping North American medical education
1913Lindlahr publishes Nature Cure
1919The American Naturopathic Association is organized
1940sPenicillin transforms the treatment of infection
1945Lust dies; licensing laws are repealed in many states over the following decades
1956National College of Naturopathic Medicine founded in Portland
1978Bastyr founded in Seattle; accreditation council formed; Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine founded
1985American Association of Naturopathic Physicians founded
1986Standardized naturopathic licensing examination established
1989Six naturopathic principles formally adopted
1990s–2000sTherapeutic order articulated; functional-medicine testing spreads into practice

Holding both sides

It would be easy to tell this history as a fall – a holistic tradition corrupted into supplement-matching. That is too simple. The nature-cure model was holistic, but its central claims about toxins and suppression did not hold up, and a profession built on them could not have safely practiced modern medicine. Dropping them was a real advance.

The loss lies elsewhere. Naturopathy discarded a flawed systemic model and never built a better one of its own. Ayurveda and classical homeopathy each kept an independent map of the person; naturopathy kept a philosophy and a toolbox, and borrowed the map. Its most systemic modern idea, the therapeutic order, is a sequence of priorities rather than a theory of the body – valuable, but easy to skip.

That is the inheritance today’s practitioners work with. Part 3 follows it into the consulting room: how naturopathic reasoning actually plays out case by case, where the therapeutic order is genuinely practiced and where it collapses into a symptom-and-supplement list, and what the research shows for the specific botanicals and nutrients naturopaths use most.