Chiropractic · Part 2 of 6
Chiropractic’s history is unusually compressed and unusually dramatic: a founding moment in an Iowa office in 1895, a father-and-son dynasty, a philosophy that was by turns scientific and frankly spiritual, a generation of practitioners who went to jail rather than stop practicing, and a decades-long campaign by organized medicine that a federal court eventually found unlawful. That arc explains a great deal about the profession’s diversity – and its occasional defensiveness – today.
Chiropractic is young as medical traditions go. Ayurveda can point to more than two thousand years of texts; homeopathy to Hahnemann’s work at the end of the eighteenth century. Chiropractic’s founding can be dated to a single week in the autumn of 1895. But the practice it formalized – healing with the hands, applied to the spine and joints – is among the oldest in medicine, and chiropractic’s story makes most sense when it begins there.
Hands on the Spine
Manipulating the spine to relieve pain is ancient and nearly universal. The Hippocratic writings of classical Greece describe techniques for traction and manipulation of the spine; Galen wrote on spinal anatomy and treated patients with manual methods; Chinese tui na, Indian massage traditions, and indigenous healing practices on several continents all include forms of joint and spinal manipulation. In Europe, lay bonesetters – often members of families that passed the craft from one generation to the next – treated joint and back complaints for centuries outside the formal medical profession. Some became famous: Sarah Mapp drew crowds in eighteenth-century England, and the bonesetter Herbert Barker was knighted in 1922 after decades of treating patients whom surgeons had failed to help.
Chiropractic was also born into a very particular moment. Late nineteenth-century America was a marketplace of competing healing systems: regular (“allopathic”) medicine, still years away from the reforms described in this site’s homeopathy series; homeopathy at the height of its influence; eclectic and botanical medicine; hydropathy; magnetic healing descended from Franz Mesmer’s theories; and, from 1874, the osteopathy of Andrew Taylor Still, whose American School of Osteopathy opened in Kirksville, Missouri, in 1892. Many of these systems shared a suspicion of the harsh drugs of the era and a belief in the body’s power to heal itself. Chiropractic emerged from that ferment, and carries its imprint still.
D.D. Palmer
Daniel David Palmer (1845–1913) was born near Port Perry, in what is now Ontario, and moved to the American Midwest as a young man, working over the years as a schoolteacher, a beekeeper, and a grocer. He was an avid self-educated reader of anatomy and physiology, and a spiritual seeker with strong interests in the metaphysical movements of his day. By the late 1880s he had established himself in Davenport, Iowa, as a magnetic healer – a practitioner who laid hands on patients on the theory that illness reflected disturbances in a vital, magnetic energy.
Palmer spent years puzzling over a question he later described as central: why one person falls ill and another, in the same circumstances, does not. His answer, when it came, grew out of his hands-on practice and his reading of anatomy together.
The Founding Moment
The story as Palmer told it runs like this. Harvey Lillard, a janitor working in Palmer’s building, had been deaf, or very nearly so, for seventeen years. Lillard reported that his hearing loss had begun when he was working in a cramped, stooped position and felt something give in his back. Palmer examined him, found a vertebra that seemed to stand out from its neighbors, and – reasoning that it might be displaced – thrust on it to move it back into position. Lillard’s hearing, Palmer reported, improved dramatically. A second case soon followed, a patient with heart trouble whose symptoms Palmer also attributed to a displaced vertebra. Palmer concluded that he had found something fundamental.
The new practice needed a name. With one of his patients, the Reverend Samuel Weed, Palmer settled on chiropractic, from the Greek cheir (hand) and praxis or praktikos (practice, action) – “done by hand.”
READING A FOUNDING STORY
Founding stories matter for what they tell us about how a tradition understands itself, and the Lillard story is told in every chiropractic history for good reason. It is also worth reading with some care. The nerve that carries hearing runs from the inner ear to the brain entirely within the skull, and does not pass through the spinal column, which makes a direct anatomical link between a thoracic or neck vertebra and deafness hard to see. The account comes almost entirely from Palmer himself, and later recollections from Lillard’s family described the episode in a more incidental way. None of this diminishes what the story meant to the profession. It does mean it is best held as a founding narrative rather than as a clinical demonstration.
The School and the Theory
Palmer began teaching in 1897, at what became the Palmer School of Chiropractic in Davenport, and over the following years set out his theory in writings that culminated in The Chiropractor’s Adjuster (1910). The claims were bold. Palmer held that some 95 percent of disease arose from displaced vertebrae – subluxations, in the term the profession came to adopt – and most of the remainder from displaced joints elsewhere. Their mechanism, in his fullest account, was interference with the flow of nerve impulses and with the working of Innate Intelligence, the organizing intelligence described in Part 1.
From early on, chiropractic described itself as three things at once: a science of the body’s structure and function, an art of skilled hands-on correction, and a philosophy of health and life. That triple self-description survives in chiropractic education today, and it helps explain why debates within the profession have always been about more than technique. Palmer wrote of his discovery in language that was by turns anatomical, philosophical, and openly spiritual, and different generations of chiropractors have emphasized different parts of that inheritance.
B.J. Palmer and the Growth of the Profession
If D.D. Palmer founded chiropractic, his son Bartlett Joshua Palmer (1882–1961) – who styled himself “the Developer” – built it into a national movement. B.J. took control of the Palmer School around 1906, after a bitter falling-out with his father that was never fully repaired, and over the following decades turned it into the largest chiropractic college in the world, with enrollment reaching into the thousands. He was a gifted promoter: in 1922 he acquired the Davenport radio station WOC, one of the earliest commercial stations in the country, and used it among other things to spread the chiropractic message.
B.J.’s leadership was also divisive. In 1924 he began promoting the neurocalometer, a heat-sensing device meant to detect subluxations by measuring skin temperature on either side of the spine, and made it effectively mandatory for Palmer-aligned chiropractors, leased at considerable cost. The backlash was severe; enrollment fell and many practitioners broke with him. In the 1930s he moved toward an exclusive focus on the top vertebra of the neck – the “Hole-in-One” technique – which became the root of the upper cervical traditions described in Part 1. B.J. remained, until his death, the most prominent champion of chiropractic as a distinct, drug-free, subluxation-centered system.
Straights and Mixers
Within a decade of its founding, chiropractic had divided along the line described in Part 1. The “straights,” led by B.J. Palmer, held that chiropractic meant the detection and correction of subluxation by hand, and nothing else. The “mixers” combined adjustment with other natural therapies – diet, hydrotherapy, electrical and physical modalities – and generally favored a broader scientific curriculum.
Two early institutions anchored the mixer side. Solon Langworthy’s American School of Chiropractic and Nature Cure, founded in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, in 1903, blended chiropractic with other drugless therapies; Langworthy co-authored Modernized Chiropractic (1906) and pushed early for formal educational standards and licensing laws – efforts the Palmers opposed. In 1906 John Howard, a former Palmer student, founded the National School of Chiropractic, later the National College of Chiropractic in the Chicago area, which became the academic home of the broad-scope tradition and emphasized laboratory sciences and diagnosis. The argument between these camps has run, in one form or another, for more than a century, and it is the historical root of the diversity a patient encounters today.
The Prosecution Era
In its first decades chiropractic was, in most of the United States, legally precarious. Without licensing laws of its own, a chiropractor could be charged with practicing medicine – or osteopathy – without a license, and thousands were prosecuted. D.D. Palmer himself was convicted in 1906 and spent several weeks in jail. In California in the early 1920s, hundreds of chiropractors chose jail over paying fines, under the rallying cry “Go to jail for chiropractic,” a campaign that helped win the state’s Chiropractic Act by ballot initiative in 1922.
One early case shaped the profession for generations. In 1907, in La Crosse, Wisconsin, a Palmer graduate named Shegataro Morikubo was charged with practicing osteopathy without a license. His defense, organized by the newly formed Universal Chiropractors Association and its attorney Tom Morris, argued that chiropractic was not osteopathy at all but a separate discipline with its own distinct philosophy – and Morikubo was acquitted. The lesson was not lost on the profession: its distinctive theory, with subluxation and Innate Intelligence at the center, was not only an intellectual commitment but a legal identity, the thing that made chiropractic something other than unlicensed medicine. That history helps explain why the founding philosophy has been defended so tenaciously, even as the scientific conversation around it has changed.
Licensure came state by state. Kansas passed the first chiropractic licensing law in 1913; Louisiana, the last, in 1974. By then chiropractic was licensed in every state, and similar recognition was spreading across Canada and beyond.
A ROAD NOT TAKEN
Osteopathy, chiropractic’s near-contemporary, began from a similar premise – that the body’s structure, and especially its musculoskeletal system, is central to health. Whether Palmer borrowed from Andrew Taylor Still has been debated since the beginning; Palmer denied it. The two professions’ later paths diverged sharply. In the United States, osteopathic physicians (DOs) progressively adopted the full scope of conventional medicine, including drugs and surgery, and today hold licensure equivalent to MDs. Chiropractic chose to remain a separate, drug-free, non-surgical profession – a choice that preserved its distinct identity, and that also kept it outside the institutions of mainstream medicine for most of the twentieth century.
The AMA, the Boycott, and Wilk v. AMA
Readers of the homeopathy series will recognize the next chapter. Organized medicine was hostile to chiropractic from the beginning, and in the 1960s that hostility became systematic. In 1963 the American Medical Association formed a Committee on Quackery whose internal documents described its goal, in effect, as containing and ultimately eliminating chiropractic. In 1966 the AMA’s House of Delegates formally labeled chiropractic an “unscientific cult.” Principle 3 of the AMA’s code of ethics was interpreted to bar medical doctors from professional association with chiropractors – from referring patients to them, accepting referrals from them, or teaching at their schools.
After internal committee documents became public in the mid-1970s, Chester Wilk and four other chiropractors sued. Wilk v. American Medical Association, filed in 1976, ended in 1987 with a ruling by federal judge Susan Getzendanner that the AMA and its co-defendants had engaged in an unlawful conspiracy to boycott chiropractors, in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act. She issued a permanent injunction; the ruling was upheld on appeal in 1990, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case. The AMA revised its ethical guidance to allow physicians to decide for themselves whether to associate with chiropractors.
HOLDING BOTH SIDES
It is important to be precise about what Wilk decided. The court found that the AMA’s boycott was an unlawful restraint of trade. It did not rule on whether chiropractic works; the judge explicitly set that question aside, and acknowledged that the AMA’s concern for patient care was a genuine one, while finding that it could have been pursued by far less restrictive means. So two things are true together: organized medicine conducted a documented, unlawful campaign to eliminate a competing profession – and the scientific questions around chiropractic’s broadest claims were real questions, which the ruling left entirely open. The profession’s long memory of that campaign, and its wariness of mainstream medicine, make sense only in light of the first. The fair evaluation of its claims requires the second.
Recognition and the Research Era
From the 1970s onward, chiropractic moved steadily toward institutional recognition. In 1972 Congress extended Medicare coverage to chiropractic manipulation of the spine to correct a subluxation – at first requiring the subluxation to be demonstrated by X-ray, a requirement later dropped. In 1974 the Council on Chiropractic Education was recognized by the U.S. Office of Education as the accrediting body for chiropractic colleges. In 1975 the National Institutes of Health sponsored a conference on the research status of spinal manipulative therapy – the first time a federal research body had convened serious discussion of the subject.
Research followed. The profession founded its own journals and research foundations, and by the late 1980s and early 1990s a series of studies had begun to shift the conversation, particularly around low back pain. A British trial led by T.W. Meade, published in the BMJ in 1990, compared chiropractic with hospital outpatient care for low back pain and reported results favoring chiropractic, though its design and interpretation were debated. RAND Corporation studies in the early 1990s assessed when spinal manipulation was appropriate for low back pain. In 1993 an Ontario government–commissioned report led by the economist Pran Manga argued for the cost-effectiveness of chiropractic care. And in 1994 the U.S. Agency for Health Care Policy and Research issued a clinical guideline on acute low back pain in adults that listed spinal manipulation among the options for early care – a watershed moment for a profession that, a decade earlier, had been fighting organized medicine in court.
Recognition spread internationally in the same period. The World Federation of Chiropractic was founded in 1988; the United Kingdom brought chiropractic under statutory regulation with the Chiropractors Act of 1994; Switzerland came to recognize chiropractors as one of its university-trained medical professions, with a chiropractic medicine program established at the University of Zurich in 2008; and the World Health Organization issued guidelines on basic training and safety in chiropractic in 2005.
The Subluxation Question Today
Greater integration sharpened, rather than settled, the profession’s founding argument. As chiropractic moved closer to mainstream health care, a growing number of chiropractors and chiropractic organizations began to reconsider the subluxation-as-cause-of-disease model. In 2010, the United Kingdom’s General Chiropractic Council – the profession’s statutory regulator there – issued guidance describing the vertebral subluxation complex as a historical concept and a theoretical model, and stating that it was not supported by clinical research evidence that would allow claims that it causes disease. Other chiropractors and organizations, particularly in the straight tradition, continue to regard subluxation-centered care as the heart of what makes chiropractic chiropractic.
The same period brought one of the profession’s most public controversies. In 2008 the British Chiropractic Association sued the science writer Simon Singh for libel over a newspaper column criticizing claims that chiropractic could help children with conditions such as colic and asthma. The association dropped the case in 2010 after an appeal court ruled that Singh’s words were protected opinion. The case became a landmark in the reform of English libel law, and prompted closer scrutiny of chiropractors’ advertising claims in the UK.
A Timeline
| YEAR | MILESTONE |
|---|---|
| 1874 / 1892 | Andrew Taylor Still announces osteopathy; the American School of Osteopathy opens in Kirksville, Missouri |
| 1895 | D.D. Palmer performs his first adjustment on Harvey Lillard in Davenport, Iowa |
| 1897 | The Palmer School of Chiropractic begins teaching |
| 1903 / 1906 | Langworthy’s American School and Howard’s National School anchor the “mixer” tradition |
| 1906 | D.D. Palmer is jailed for practicing medicine without a license; B.J. Palmer takes control of the Palmer School |
| 1907 | The Morikubo case establishes chiropractic’s legal identity as distinct from osteopathy |
| 1913 | Kansas passes the first chiropractic licensing law; D.D. Palmer dies |
| 1924 | B.J. Palmer’s neurocalometer triggers a revolt within the profession |
| 1963 / 1966 | The AMA forms its Committee on Quackery and labels chiropractic an “unscientific cult” |
| 1972 / 1974 | Medicare coverage for spinal manipulation; federal recognition of chiropractic accreditation; Louisiana becomes the last state to license chiropractors |
| 1975 | NIH-sponsored conference on the research status of spinal manipulative therapy |
| 1987 / 1990 | Wilk v. AMA finds the AMA’s boycott unlawful; the ruling is upheld on appeal |
| 1994 | U.S. federal low back pain guideline lists spinal manipulation as a care option; UK Chiropractors Act |
| 2010 | UK General Chiropractic Council guidance on the subluxation concept; BCA v. Singh ends |
None of this history is offered as a substitute for asking whether chiropractic’s specific clinical claims hold up under testing – that is a separate question, and Part 3 takes it up directly. What this history establishes is that chiropractic is neither a fringe curiosity nor a finished science. It is a young, hands-on profession that grew out of an ancient practice and a very particular American moment, survived a sustained and unlawful effort to eliminate it, won licensure and a real place in health care, and has been arguing with itself, productively and sometimes painfully, about its own founding ideas ever since.
