Traditional Chinese Medicine · Article
The Japanese history of acupuncture and their herbal medicine practice started in the 5th-8th century.
It was imported through Korea to Japan but was reinterpreted and redesigned in a distinctly Japanese way.
In the Asuka and Nara periods (6th-8th century) Japan began integrating similar features to the Chinese model; Yin/Yang, pulse diagnosis, herbal medicines, Zang/Fu organ functions, moxibustion and Five Phase Theory. Their important medical text, called the Ishimpo compiled by Tamba no Yasuyori translated and interpreted Chinese Medicine concepts and treatments from China.
It was customary, at the end of a Chinese dynasty, for the new dynasty to destroy symbols or artifacts from the previous regime. It asserted their power and was designed to remove remembrance of the old order and recognize the new one. As a result many of China’s original texts were destroyed but fortunately, the Ishimpo text was protected, and has preserved this ancient information.
The Heian Period
From 794-1185 followed the Nara period. The 50th emperor, Kanmu moved the capital to Heian, now Kyoto. Chinese medicine had a substantial influence at this time. However, physicians started to adapt their approaches to match the Japanese geography, environment, diet and climate, as well as differing disease patterns. Chinese approaches were modified and customized, especially herbal treatment, to their own situation.
The Muromachi Period
From 1336-1573 is also called the Ashikaga period after the ruler’s name. Buddhism became the most influential religion of the time. And while practitioners had been copying the Chinese modernization of existing herbal practices and interpretations, momentum shifted to studying the ancient classical texts directly resulting in the creation and formation of the Koho-ha or ancient formula schools. This revived the treatment and principles of the Shang Han Lun and Jin Gui Yao Lue.
The Muromachi period was also an era of civil wars and it was Japan’s warring state period. It was a time of political dysfunction and allowed European trade which brought gunpowder and weapons altering Japanese warfare.
The Edo period
Edo was the former name of Tokyo. It is called the Tokugawa period, after the Shogun, and extended from 1603-1868 and was a period of isolation from the world and intended to end civil unrest. Trade was restricted to a few island ports and there was limited interaction with the outside world. It was designed to keep Christianity out and prevent regional lords from aligning with outside powers.
During this era, a rigid social hierarchy was established to maintain order, along with the urbanization of cities and the rise of a wealthy merchant class.
Other aspects of Japanese life changed, art and culture flourished with the development of unique styles, an example being ukiyo-e, woodblock prints. And while exposure to Chinese Medicine had occurred in the 5th or 6th centuries with the adoption and application of their theories, it wasn’t until this period of Japanese isolation that their unique treatment approach to herbal medicine called Kampo developed and took form.
Practitioners continued to study the classical ancient texts, the Shang Han Lun, and the Jin Gui Yao Lue which described patterns of disease and treatment through herbal medicine. Japanese cultural belief however also recognized the strong association between the vitality of an individual’s Hara, or abdomen, and its reflection of the strength of a person’s spiritual and physical energy.
Building on these traditions Dr. Toto Yoshimatsu developed and refined the abdominal exam called Fukushin which became an important component of diagnosis and herbal prescribing.
Through palpation of specific regions of the abdomen, practitioners assessed findings such as strength or weakness, tension or laxity, temperature, tenderness, and pain. These findings were interpreted as indications of underlying patterns of imbalance and helped guide the selection of appropriate herbal formulas.
By integrating the information from the abdominal exam, with the patient’s symptoms, a specific pattern of imbalance or dysfunction could be identified, called the SHOH, which directed herbal treatment to the precise classic herbal formula needed to correct the pattern.
This style of herbal practice asserts that diagnosis determines treatment and the treatment confirms the diagnosis.
Also during the Edo period, Japan came under the influence of Dutch physicians and were instructed in anatomy, physiology, surgery, western pharmacology and diagnoses through Dutch medical texts. This created factions, occurring simultaneously, which were often at odds with each other; traditional classical Chinese Medicine, Japanese empirical clinical treatments and Western Medicine.
The Meiji Restoration
From 1868-1912. During this time, a shift in the direction of medical treatment occurred, when in 1874 a law was enacted adopting Western medical care for the entire national health system, and made it a requirement of study to become a physician. Acupuncture and moxibustion were considered marginal for care and while not forbidden their practice declined substantially.
At the same time Kampo related education was discontinued and was only able to survive through individual practitioners and family traditional use.
Acupuncture
In Japan, there are many acupuncture schools whose practitioners follow ancient traditions that differ from the meridian based Japanese acupuncture commonly taught in the US. Each offers distinct technical and diagnostic approaches to treatment.
The Major Schools
Pre World War 2
Toyohari, 1920’s-1940’s. Traditional acupuncture in Japan is commonly referred to as Meridian acupuncture. It focuses on balancing the Qi in the body using pulse diagnosis primarily, meridian palpation and gentle abdominal palpation, and their palpation with gentle needling techniques. It emphasizes treating the source of the problem while also addressing symptoms.
Mubun, late 1500’s. This school emphasizes abdominal diagnosis, or the Hara, and treatment uses a needle tapping technique on the abdomen to assess the body’s energetic.
Sawada Style, early 1900’s. A constitutional approach to problems with a standardized constitutional treatment with extensive moxibustion.
Shonishin, Edo period, mid 1700’s. Is a classic style used in pediatrics or depleted elderly people which uses stroking and tapping techniques using specialized instruments instead of needles. Treatment traces the flow of each meridian’s qi flow to rebalance and harmonize the system.
Post World War 2
As the twentieth century progressed, even though acupuncture and Kampo herbs had been considered less relevant, its practices continued to evolve in ways that were very different from their Chinese counterparts.
The Japanese style developed multiple distinctive approaches and techniques using a very thorough evaluation and palpation of the body, the meridian channels and the tissues throughout the body.
Acupuncture treatments also evolved differently than in China, using very thin needles inserted shallowly with gentle stimulation, whereas treatment in China involved deep needling, with thick needles and strong stimulation.
Manaka Therapy. Many innovations integrated into the Japanese interpretation of Chinese Medicine, post WW 2 were exemplified by Dr Yasuo Manaka’s Topological Society. It brought together contemporary practitioners, with the mandate to pursue original clinical treatment applications, the expansion of therapeutic approaches and developing more sophisticated diagnostic methods.
Their work contributed to refinements in abdominal diagnosis, the use of electrical stimulation of acupuncture points and established methods to clinically evaluate acupuncture treatments. Important areas of investigation were the clinical applications using the Eight Extraordinary Vessels and Channel Divergents. While written about in ancient texts, their clinical application had received limited attention in clinical practice. The Society developed and investigated treatment protocols for their use, and came to recognize their ability to treat deep imbalances within the body.
Ultimately, their clinical research helped evolve the Japanese perspective of Chinese medicine to offer new modern treatment protocols to address contemporary diseases being seen in the modern era. Its most integrative and recognized practitioner in the US was Dr Miki Shima, whose seminars and books on Kampo and the Extra vessels and Channel Divergents allowed advancement in supportive therapies for autoimmune diseases and cancer.
Fukaya Style. This style of practitioners are specialized in moxibustion chronic conditions and patients with deficiencies or weaknesses. Diagnosis uses palpation and how the person responds to treatment.
Ryodoraku Style. Developed by Dr Nakatani, it measures electrical skin resistance to determine autonomic and functional problems, and uses electrical stimulation of needles.
Kiiko Matsumoto Style, based on Dr Nagano’s style. She has become a strong influence in the US for her blended style of assessing structural problems and abdominal patterns and areas of pain to palpation.
Shakuju. Treatment is a form of abdominal diagnosis using contact superficial needling, rapidly and over the area. It is designed to move the Qi toward greater harmonization rather than treating specific channel issues.
Twentieth Century Japanese Herbal Prescribing, known as Kampo
Within the framework of a modern post World War 2 Japan, limitations in western care for the aging population became recognized. This offered opportunities for the reintroduction of acupuncture and Kampo in a contemporary context of disease.
With the help of physician proponents such as Drs. Otsuka, Yumoto and Yakazu, Kampo became modernized, revitalized and transformed into a therapeutic alternative that physicians could use empirically. This practice approach demonstrated that herbal treatment could, manage chronic symptoms, enhance the quality of life in the elderly and blend well with Western medicine.
Traditional Chinese medicine relies on observing the patient and utilizing the pulse in both acupuncture and herbal treatments. In Japan, the use of the abdomen is considered an essential addition for diagnosis believing it is more accurate, repeatable and reliable than just the pulse.
Japanese herbal therapy, called Kampo, believes that the pulse is subject to variations related to external influences from people ingesting caffeinated /and or sugary drinks, smoking, taking supplements or western medications and having significant stressors, which can affect the “true” pulse. This approach incorporates the pulse but additionally relies on the abdominal exam for an essential source of clinical information. It is believed the abdomen reflects a person’s Hara, a person’s physical, psychological and spiritual centers. The exam divides the abdomen into distinct anatomical areas that represent different organ systems, and using palpation, the practitioner can determine variations in abdominal musculature, its strength or weakness areas of tension, temperature, and sensitivities allowing the identification of imbalances within a specific organ system.
Kampo prescribing then matches the symptoms with the abdominal pattern which together determines the exact formula needed for the pattern of imbalance. This pattern, called the SHOH, directs the practitioner to the specific classic Chinese herbal formula needed for correct treatment. And as disease manifestations change the SHOH also changes, requiring reassessing and adjusting treatment to match the new current pattern.
Kampo therapy was so successful and became integrated into the western medical model, and training was incorporated into medical school curriculums. Its revival resulted in the government of Japan, in 1967, including and expanding Kampo herbal formula coverage and payment under the national insurance program. Today approximately 170 Kampo herbal formulations are available, and a significant percentage of physicians in Japan utilize Kampo in daily practice and hospital care and over two thirds of gynecologists use it as a regular therapeutic modality.
Before the Meiji Restoration, 1868-1912 Japanese traditional medicine, which included acupuncture, herbal prescriptions, moxibustion, dietary recommendations and physical therapies could be part of a practitioner’s practice. In 1874 reforms separated acupuncture and herbal therapies.
Currently, only licensed physicians can prescribe herbal formulas and medical students are taught Japanese herbal therapies.
Acupuncture licensing only allows the practice of acupuncture, without the authority to prescribe herbal formulas.
